THEY ALL WORE A STAR
In the Fight for the Four-Gun Battery
in the Battle of Resaca, Georgia, May 15, 1864
by Robert G. Miller
Version II of this book is being prepared for publication. The author strongly advises waiting for it.
Version II is much better organized and has more narrative to guide and explain what the writers are telling us. There are more stories, which help fill in some gaps. Maps and formatting are better. Overall, the book is more complete and more readable. In effect, more interesting.
Quotes from original sources are like living history. They make up this story about the lives of soldiers and their very first battle, in which they assaulted a battery to try to break the Confederate line at Resaca, Georgia, on May 15, 1864. It was the first full engagement of the Atlanta Campaign, with 100,000 soldiers under General William T. Sherman surrounding General Joseph Johnston’s 50,000, who were dug in on a fortress of hills. They were under Daniel Butterfield’s division, in General Joseph Hooker’s 20th Corps, the “Star Corps.” Leading the assaulting brigade was future President Benjamin Harrison’s 70th Indiana Regiment.
This book evolved from the author’s research into the experiences of his great-great-grandfather’s regiment. Joseph Peters was killed in the assault and the only information available was the letter sent to the widow. In following the trail of his company, the individual stories of the regiment, brigade, and corps became more and more interesting and those about the battle more and more confusing. No amount of summarizing or retelling can replace what those soldiers tell about their own experiences, as sort of a tapestry woven from the yarns they spun in their letters, diaries, and regimental histories. Combined with the versions of events from Official Records and newspaper accounts, a more honest and fascinating history of the battle emerged.
Part One follows the brigade led by future President Benjamin Harrison, from enlistment until the start of the Atlanta Campaign. The soldiers tell of the experiences which hardened them for the battle, starting with terrible marches trying to catch up with Bragg’s army, yet missing the Battles of Perryville and Stones River but arriving just in time to witness the horrible results. Then, in separated in lonely outposts, they endured harsh winters while guarding railroads and looking for guerillas in Kentucky. Many of them did not survive the hard marches in the heat or the diseases of the winter. All during that year and a half the generals who would determine their fate were showing their abilities and ambitions in other battles, as told in the book by stories not included in Official Records or most histories. After the Battle of Chattanooga, they marched over the mountains from Nashville in harsh winter weather to prepare for the coming Campaign for Atlanta in drills, parades, and mock battles.
Part Two finds the soldiers on their way to the Battle of Resaca. Because the story has been pieced together from many sources, many details of the battle are new, and differ radically from historical accounts in many respects. The author matched details of each individual story, what the writer saw and did, reconciling discrepancies where he could and exposing them where he could not — clearly revealing how the dedication of some and the failure of others affected the outcome of the battle.
by George H. Blakeslee, 129th Illinois Infantry
This is how he remembered it.
“We had to fight Hooker’s command here or else the battery never would have been taken … They all wore a star.” – Max Van Den Corput, CSA